Showing posts with label relationships. Show all posts
Showing posts with label relationships. Show all posts

Thursday, July 26, 2012

People's Court: 7-25-12

I Finally Found You After Six Years!
Peggy and Sharon are suing each other for $3,000.00. Peggy attempted to rent a house from Sharon 6 years ago. Peggy explains that so much time has gone by because she has not been able to find Sharon. She happened to be driving behind her one day and recognized her. She followed her, blocked her car in with her own car and called the police. Sharon was able to maneuver her car to get out and drive away. Peggy follows her again and thinks they are going to have a burger together! Sharon had pulled into a parking lot with a McDonald's. She does not want to eat with Peggy! She wants to get away from her. None of this has anything to do with the lawsuit. It does illustrate that Peggy is a very determined lady! Here is the story: Peggy was going to rent a house from Sharon. They met, did a walkthrough and signed a lease. Peggy handed over $1200.00, the security deposit and first month's rent. After this, Sharon tells Peggy that once a month someone is going to inspect the house. Peggy gets upset over this, she did not want someone checking on her, she said she wanted her money back. Peggy was not going to live under those conditions. Sharon offers to give her back half, Peggy wanted it all back. After all, only minutes had passed since signing the lease and giving Sharon the money. Sharon finally tells her that she will not return any of it and she can take her to court. Peggy could not find Sharon to serve papers for a lawsuit and then she sees her! So, here we are, 6 years later in court. The reason Peggy is suing for $3,000.00 and not $1200.00, is to include interest for the past 6 years. So much time has gone by, can Peggy still sue? She is very lucky, the statue of limitations has not run out! Now we hear the landlord's story. She claims that Peggy came to the meeting with her daughter, 3 children and a very big dog. She overheard them talking about fixing up the rooms for the children. She was worried about her property because she was not going to be living nearby. She says she told Peggy about the monthly inspections before the agreement was signed and the money paid. That really does not sound truthful. I do not think Peggy would have agreed to these terms. She said Peggy called her days later and said she found another place. Another statement that does not have the ring of truth. It does not seem to matter that the stories do not match. The monthly inspections do not seem to be unreasonable to the court. I would not want to live with those conditions. Would you want someone conducting monthly inspections of your home? The signed agreement limits Sharon to keep $600.00. She has to return $600.00 to Peggy, since she had no right to keep the entire amount. Her counterclaim for $3,000.00 is dismissed. I do not think the counterclaim makes any sense, she is suing Peggy for breaking the lease. She was already keeping her money, why would she be entitled to receive more money? Legally, she is not entitled. That is a good thing. It is curious that Peggy amended her lawsuit to match the amount of the counterclaim! A coincidence? Something to think about. These two women are like oil and water. Thank goodness Peggy never moved into Sharon's house. There was never anything good that would have come of that relationship. Some things happen for a reason! Let me know what you think.

What Are The Two Best Days Of A Boat Owner's Life?
(The answer to this question will be at the end of this case)
Fred wanted to buy John's boat. John sold his boat to someone else. Fred is suing John for survey costs, financing fees and the difference in the purchase of another boat. Why would he think that John would be responsible to pay these costs? Fred tells us that after he saw the boat, he offered John a deposit to hold it and John refused the check. Fred wanted to have some tests done, a survey and a sea trial, to make sure the boat was worth the $24,000 he was planning to pay for it. He met with John several times to see the boat, drive the boat and have professionals test the boat. On their last meeting, Fred makes up his mind, tells John he is definitely going to buy the boat and offers another deposit check. Fred prepares a written agreement that John signs, and still, no money changes hands. Fred claims that John told him he was a man of his word, he would not sell the boat out from under him. When it seems the deal is well underway, Fred contacts John again for an additional test. Fred says the surveyor e-mailed him regarding another test. John agrees that Fred called him, but said he was going to walk away from the deal because there might be a catastrophic failure. These two men seem to be having entirely two different conversations! Yet, they both appear so truthful. John contacts someone else that was interested in the boat. They meet and the person buys the boat immediately. Fred thinks he is still going to buy the boat and contacts John. Fred is told the boat is sold and he is upset because of all the time and money he has put into the anticipated purchase. Fred purchases another boat that is not as nice as this one and is more expensive. He wants to hold John responsible for these costs. He is not able to prove his case and leaves the court very disappointed. John is very satisfied with the verdict and is still convinced that Fred got cold feet and was not going to buy the boat. This is a good example of getting everything in writing from the beginning of a transaction. If this is not possible, communicate through e-mail so there is proof of intentions. I feel bad for Fred because he seemed so sincere about wanting this boat. He was trying to be a very careful buyer but seemed to be taking too long to make a final decision. What do you think?
(answer: the day he buys the boat and the day he sells it!)

You Ruined My Pants!
Patricia was walking past Ming's chinese restaurant when his employee was cleaning the sidewalk. When she got to work, she noticed her pants had been splattered with bleach. She called the store to let them know. After work, she went into the store and showed the manager the damage to her pants and asked for $78.00, the cost of the pants. Why is she suing for $379.00? She wants to be paid to replace the pants and for her costs of filing the claim. How much did she pay for the pants? $46.41. She received a discount since she opened a store account. This would not be an offer she would be able to get again. Patrica would only be entitled to receive the depreciated value of the pants, even though she wore them for the first time that day. Before she can get anything, we need to know if the store employee is responsible for the damage. The sidewalk is cleaned everyday. The employee puts out yellow markers to block half of the sidewalk. The employee pours a bleach solution and sprays the sidewalk with water. Patricia says she walked on the dry part of the sidewalk and noticed the bleach spots when she got to work. The employee told the owner, she walked on the wet part. He said he remembered her because of where she walked. That is why they were not going to pay for the damage. It does not seem believable that the employee remembered her with all of the people that must walk by in the morning. It does not seem believable that she would walk in the wet area in the direct line of the water spraying from the hose. Because this story is not believable and Patricia's story is believable, Patricia wins. She does not win $379.00, she is awarded $50.00, the depreciated value of the pants. In the hallway, Patricia says it was about the principle. The manager was rude to her and that is why she is here today. Also, she still has to walk in front of the store everyday and she crosses the street when the sidewalk is being cleaned. The owner says his employee is honorable and he continues to believe him. The owner needs to realize, if something does not make sense, it is probably not true. What do you think?

Please share your thoughts in the comments. Thank you for joining me today.

Of all the things you wear, your expression is the most important.
-Janet Lane




Thursday, July 5, 2012

People's Court: 7-4-12 ** Silver Coins *** A Tree *** Allergies

Happy 4th of July!!!!! 

We are responsible for the decisions we make. Hopefully we make these decisions with the best intentions. To blatantly take advantage of someone is inexcusable. To ignore a past relationship is so so sad. And to ignore our surroundings is not always the best idea. The following cases illustrate these situations. 

Finding a great deal at a flea market is a wonderful feeling. Getting taken advantage of is another story. Daniel thought he discovered a deal at a local flea market. A vendor was selling silver coins. He even showed Daniel a book of coins to prove they were real. After the coins were purchased, Daniel took them to have them authenticated. He learned he paid $1100.00 for nothing. These coins had no value. The question is: Did the vendor know this when he sold them? And if he did, why is he taking advantage of someone? If the vendor did not act guilty, leaving the flea market directly after the sale, I would think he did not know the coins did not have any value. This theory is dispelled quickly as the vendor tells his story. He is not believable. He is rude to the Judge, pointing his finger at her and raising his voice. I am surprised she did not throw him out of the courtroom. The more he talked, the guiltier he appeared. He does have to pay the money back. I am so glad it turned out this way. People do not deserve to be taken advantage of. Of course, we all have to do our due diligence to protect ourselves.

Two neighbors in court over a tree. What a shame, these two people were good friends at one time. They have lived next to each other for over 20 years. Why does it wind up this way? Thomas claims that his neighbor, Joan, had one of his trees cut down after the snowstorm last Halloween. There was damage to trees on both properties. Thomas says this particular tree was not damaged. He thinks since it was so close to the property line, when the clean-up was done on Joan's property, they cut this tree down. Joan tells us she paid her friend's cousin $50.00 to clean up 2 damaged trees. If this tree was not damaged, why would someone cut it down. They wouldn't! Thomas should be glad someone did free work for him and instead of dragging his friend into court, he should be thanking her. He does not get the money he is asking for. Joan does not have to pay him over $3000.00 for a tree that was damaged in a snowstorm. What brings us to this point where we can not even talk to each other in a civil manner? We need a courtroom setting to resolve our problems? These two people were friends and that should count for something. In the hallway, they both agree the friendship does not exist anymore.

Denise is highly allergic to animals. She moves into an apartment building that allows animals. After several months she develops such a severe allergic reaction she winds up in the hospital. When she decides to move out without proper notice, she wants her security deposit back. So much of what she says does not make sense. She tells us the apartment manager told her no pets were allowed in the building, yet the lease she signed does not state this information. The lease gives the specifics of the restrictions of having a pet. They have to be approved by management and there are specific rules to follow. Denise also tells us that on at least two occasions she has to deal with dog feces near her door and the entrance to the building. She does not contact management at this point. She does not submit a complaint. She does not give notice to move out. It is not until 5 months later, when she gets sick, she moves out. How does she not see dogs for the entire time she has lived there? Denise does not get back her security deposit. We all need to take responsibility for our lives. Knowing she had a severe allergy, she should have made sure there were no pets in the building. Why put her health at risk? There are many ways to rationalize our behavior. In this case, I am baffled by the decisions that Denise made!

Please let me know what you think. Thank you for joining me today!

Happiness will not come to those who fail to appreciate what they already have.
-Unknown

Submit your favorite quotes and sayings!


Tuesday, June 26, 2012

People's Court: 6-25-12: Promises

Why do people agree to something and then back out afterwards? This seems to be very common. It is as if their word is not enough. There was a time a handshake was meaningful.

Families are very important. When two people get married it is so nice when the families mesh. This case is about a family torn apart. Traditionally, the bride's family pays for the wedding. The groom's mom paid for the rehearsal dinner and then agrees to pay for the invitations and their family's guests. She denies agreeing to these additional expenses, yet starts making payments after the wedding. After paying back $300.00 she stops making the payments. Her son does not want his new father-in-law to know this, so he continues the payments with his own money. At some point he comes clean and that is when his father-in-law decides to sue for the money. Mother and son do not have the best history. Instead of trying to repair this relationship, these actions are going to further the break. The shame of it is, they do not just make this case about the debt.  Information is brought up about the groom's childhood. This is not necessary to discuss on national TV. The mother is beside herself with emotion. This is so difficult for her. She feels she will never see her grandchildren since her and her son are not talking. She is found liable to pay the balance of what she owes. It is a shame that a family falls apart over $1600.00. I hope this family can get professional counseling and all get along. Do it for the sake of the grandchildren!

A woman lends her ex-boyfriend her car and he gets a parking ticket. Why would she lend her car to someone who has not talked to her for over a month? He calls her out of the blue and tells her a sob story. She falls for it and lends him her car. She has also given him a bus pass to sell. He claims this is a scam but can not prove it. He admits owing her the $20.00 for the bus pass, yet denies that he used her car. He is so unbelievable. He does have to pay her back for the parking ticket, the late fees associated with it and the money for the bus pass. More importantly, this woman needs to stop letting people take advantage of her. She did not hear from this man for over a month and then she lends him her car. He insults her by denying he was ever her boyfriend and describes their relationship as friends with benefits. She needs to protect herself from people like this. Never lend your car to anyone, the consequences can be so much more than parking tickets!

Please let me know what you think. Thank you for joining me today.


Happiness is when what you think, what you say, and what you do are in harmony.